Two pies go head-to-head for the title.
Which Is The Most Popular Thanksgiving Holiday Pie?
Apple pie or pumpkin pie? Pick only one!
More than half of all Americans plan to finish their Thanksgiving dinner with a slice of pie.
Apple and pumpkin pie are the top two choices, but which one comes out on top?
Instacart’s 2024 data shows that apple pies lead in year-round sales, while pumpkin pies are more popular specifically during the Thanksgiving holiday.
Geography plays a role in pie preferences, with apple pie favored in the Northeast and pumpkin pie more popular in the Midwest and South.
Pumpkin pie’s seasonal availability and connection to American harvest traditions make it a special and anticipated dessert for Thanksgiving.
Apple pie symbolizes home and tradition for many.