The Most Popular Easter Candy in 2025 Is . . .

Instacart did a list earlier this month, and as recent as this week, a new survey came out, looking for our favorite Easter candies (and it’s NOT PEEPS). Can you guess what IS the #1 candy is?

#5: Robin Eggs, 9% (the Easter-themed Whoppers.

#4: Jelly beans, 12%.

#3: Cadbury Creme Eggs, also 13%.

#2: Chocolate Easter bunnies, 13%.

#1: Reese’s Peanut Butter Eggs, with 26% of the vote

(they also topped Instacart’s most-purchased list).